Back to blog

SEO Competitor Analysis: Step-by-Step Guide + Template

SEO Course

SEO Competitor Analysis: Step-by-Step Guide + Template

By Forsa | SEO Audit and Technical SEO Specialist

How to do an SEO competitor analysis: find your real search competitors, run keyword, content and link gap checks, compare AI visibility and plan fixes.

Updated 31 October 2026 · Part of the SEO guide series

Short answer: An SEO competitor analysis compares your site with the sites that rank for the searches you want, to find what they do better and where they leave gaps. Identify your real search competitors (often different from business competitors), then compare keywords, content, links, technical quality and visibility in AI answers. The goal is a short list of actions: pages to create, pages to improve and links to pursue.

Step 1: Find your real search competitors

Business competitors and search competitors are often different. A local bakery competes for "cake decorating ideas" with recipe blogs and video sites, not with the bakery down the road.

  1. List 10 to 20 keywords that matter most to your business.
  2. Search each one (signed out, in your target location) and note the domains on page one.
  3. Count how often each domain appears. The domains that appear most are your SERP competitors.
  4. Group them: direct competitors (sell the same thing), content competitors (publishers, blogs) and marketplaces or directories.

Pick three to five to analyze in depth: usually two direct competitors and one or two content competitors.

Example: Counting SERP Competitors

(Illustrative.) A small online plant shop searches 12 keywords, such as "how to repot a monstera", "best low light houseplants" and "buy fiddle leaf fig". The domains on page 1 are counted:

Domain typeAppearances (of 12 searches)Group
Large garden magazine9Content competitor
Two plant retailers7 and 5Direct competitors
Video platform6Marketplace or platform
Home improvement chain4Direct competitor

The shop decides to study the magazine, the 2 retailers and the video results, and notes that the magazine wins how-to searches while the retailers win buying searches, so it needs a different page for each intent.

Step 2: Keyword gap analysis

Using a keyword research tool with competitor data:

  • Missing keywords: keywords competitors rank for and you do not.
  • Weak keywords: keywords where you rank on page two or lower and competitors rank on page one.
  • Shared keywords: where you both rank; watch movements here.

Filter for relevance and intent. A competitor ranking for a topic you cannot serve is not a gap.

Step 3: Content gap and quality benchmark

For each priority keyword, open the top-ranking competitor pages and compare:

Question What to look for
Format Guide, comparison, tool, product page, video?
Coverage Which subtopics and questions do they answer that you don't?
Evidence Original data, examples, expert input, screenshots?
Freshness When was it last meaningfully updated?
Usability Is it easy to scan, fast on mobile, clear about the next step?

Your goal is not to copy or out-length them, but to be more useful: answer the question faster, add what is missing and remove what is not needed.

Step 4: Backlink gap

Compare which sites link to competitors but not to you. Look for patterns, such as industry associations, media types, resource pages, partners or tools directories, rather than single links. Those patterns show which link-earning tactics are realistic in your niche. See link building and authority for how to act on them within Google's policies.

Check Competitor Pages Quickly

Run your page and a competitor's page through the free SEO audit and compare load time, mobile readiness, titles, headings and structured data detection side by side. It will not explain every ranking difference, but it shows quickly whether technical basics are part of the gap.

Step 5: Technical and experience comparison

Check the basics against competitors:

  • Are their key pages indexed and fast on mobile?
  • Do they use structured data that earns rich results (reviews, products, FAQs where eligible)?
  • Is their site structure easier to navigate, with clearer internal links to important pages?

Technical issues rarely explain the whole gap, but a slow or poorly structured site makes everything else harder.

Step 6: Compare visibility in AI answers

More searches now show AI-generated answers, and people also ask AI assistants directly. Check which brands and sources appear when you ask the questions your customers ask, and which pages are cited. Our AI citation analyzer shows which sources AI engines cite for a query, which helps you see whether competitors are referenced where you are not.

Step 7: Turn findings into actions

Gap found Action
Competitor ranks for a relevant topic you don't cover Create a page that matches the intent better
You rank on page two for a priority keyword Improve the existing page: coverage, clarity, internal links
Competitors earn links from a type of site you don't Plan a linkable asset or outreach to that site type
Competitor pages are cited in AI answers and yours are not Add clear answers, original information and better structure to your page
Competitor has a technical advantage Fix speed, indexing or structured data issues

Prioritize by business value and effort; you cannot close every gap at once. Our guide to search intent and SERP analysis helps you judge which format each gap needs.

SEO competitor analysis template

Section What to record
Competitors 3 to 5 SERP competitors and why they were chosen
Keyword gaps Top 20 missing or weak keywords with intent and value
Content benchmark For 5 priority keywords: their page vs yours (format, coverage, evidence, freshness)
Link gaps Site types linking to them, examples, realistic tactics
Technical notes Speed, indexing, structured data differences
AI visibility Questions tested, brands and sources cited
Actions Top 10 actions ranked by value and effort, with owners and dates

How often to repeat it

Run a full analysis when you start a new SEO plan, then refresh it quarterly. Track rankings and new competitor content monthly so surprises do not build up.

FAQs

How do I do an SEO competitor analysis?

Find the domains that rank for your important keywords, then compare their keywords, content, backlinks, technical quality and AI visibility with yours, and turn the biggest relevant gaps into a prioritized action list.

Who are my SEO competitors?

The sites that rank on page one for the keywords you want, which may include publishers, marketplaces and directories, not only businesses that sell what you sell.

What is a content gap analysis?

It is the part of competitor analysis that finds topics and questions competitors cover and you do not, and checks where their content is more complete or useful than yours.

Do I Need a Paid Tool?

Not to start. Manual searches, Search Console and free checkers can show the main gaps for a small site. Paid tools save time and give competitor keyword and backlink estimates, which are useful but are estimates, so treat them as directional.

Should I Copy What Competitors Do?

No. Learn what searchers want from the results, then be more useful, accurate or specific. Copying competitors gives you a page that is no better than theirs and may not rank.

How often should I update a competitor analysis?

Do a full review quarterly and monitor rankings and new competitor content monthly.